The U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Committee is encouraging individual sports to consider “category qualifiers” — classified in some sports as “open” categories — to ensure transgender athletes will have events to participate in once they reach puberty.
The USOPC finalized its so-called position paper at its
board meeting earlier this month and released it Monday, addressing a proposed
path forward for transgender participation in sports.
The committee’s recommendations were based, it said, on the
principle that science and “fairness” should guide all major decisions. As part
of that, the two-page paper said the emphasis in youth sports (before children
reach puberty) should be to push for as much participation as possible.
“Here, we believe the science is clearer that there is much
less physical safety or competitive risk, or sporting advantage based on
physiological sex characteristics,” the paper said.
The federation said it wanted to follow the science in
determining the conditions under which transgender athletes can compete once
they reach puberty, which triggers significant differences in testosterone
production between biologically born males and females. It acknowledged that
the “sport landscape may leave currently competing athletes feeling uncertain
regarding potential shifts in their eligibility status.”
It used weight classes in boxing, handicaps in golf and
different classifications in Paralympic sports, which engender a fair amount of
debate themselves, as examples of ways athletes are grouped into different
categories.
“There’s already that opportunity to delineate based on
different things, and every sport is different,” said Nitra Rucker, the USOPC’s
director of diversity, equity and inclusion. “So you have to look at it on a
sport-by-sport basis.”
The British Triathlon federation is among the few that have
adopted an open category, which is open to “all individuals including male,
transgender and those nonbinary who were male sex at birth,” it said.
Separately, it said, the female category is for “those who are the female sex
at birth.”
World Aquatics, which released new rules earlier this year
that effectively banned transgender females from competing against biologically
born females, also said it was proposing an open category.
World Athletics, which is expected to release its revised
policies for transgender athletes next year, most recently said that open
categories were not among its current considerations.
Some transgender athletes have criticized the concept of
open categories, saying transgender females should be able to compete in female
categories, the way swimmer Lia Thomas did at this year’s NCAA championships.
Others, such as Caitlyn Jenner, believe transgender females would have an
unfair advantage in a female category but are skeptical about open categories
because they doubt there will be enough athletes in them to stage a legitimate
competition.
Rucker acknowledged the difficulties the USOPC had in coming
up with a position that would satisfy everyone, but said the federation needed
to weigh in.
“I think it’s important to make sure that we have a voice in
this conversation in order to support our athletes, all of our athletes, in
this space,” she said.