Funds that track benchmark indices such as the Bloomberg Commodity Index are expected to sell roughly $6.1bn of silver and $5.6bn of gold between January 8 and January 15, according to estimates from JPMorgan. The rebalancing process, which takes place once a year, is designed to reset index weightings after significant price movements, forcing passive funds to adjust their holdings accordingly.
This year’s adjustment comes at a sensitive moment for precious metals. Gold prices climbed more than 60 per cent in 2025, while silver surged more than 160 per cent, leaving both markets elevated as 2026 gets under way. Since Tuesday’s close, gold has slipped about 0.6 per cent and silver has fallen by more than 4 per cent, as investors brace for the anticipated selling.
Analysts say the scale of recent price gains means the rebalancing could have a more pronounced market impact than in calmer years. JPMorgan estimates that silver will see the largest net selling of any commodity, equivalent to around 10 per cent of the total value of open derivatives contracts on Comex.
Despite the near-term pressure, some market participants view the forced selling as a potential buying opportunity. During last year’s rebalancing window, similar sales were absorbed by strong demand, ultimately pushing prices higher rather than lower.
Attention is also turning to agricultural markets, particularly cocoa, which has been reintroduced into the Bloomberg Commodity Index. As a result, index-tracking funds are expected to buy cocoa contracts equivalent to around 30 per cent of open interest on the Ice exchange in London, according to estimates from ED&F Man. The anticipated demand has already been cited as a factor behind cocoa’s sharp rally in November, when the index announced its inclusion.
While some speculative investors may have positioned themselves ahead of the rebalancing, analysts say the scale of index-related buying could still provide meaningful support to cocoa prices. The market has been closely focused on the rebalancing for months, amid concerns it could trigger short covering in London.
Cocoa prices fell nearly 50 per cent in 2025, following record-breaking rallies in 2023 and 2024 that were driven by severe supply shortages in West Africa, which accounts for more than two-thirds of global cocoa production.
