A major nine-year study led by the University of Bristol has challenged the routine use of dialysis for older people with kidney failure, finding that alternative approaches to managing the condition can deliver similar overall outcomes in terms of life expectancy and quality of life.

The research, described as the first randomised study of its kind, suggests that older patients could benefit from a less medicalised approach focused on managing symptoms and providing responsive care at home, rather than automatically undergoing dialysis.

Dialysis is a treatment that filters waste products and excess fluid from the blood when the kidneys can no longer function properly. However, the procedure often requires patients to spend several hours in hospital multiple times a week and carries the risk of complications.

Project lead Professor Fergus Caskey, a kidney consultant at Bristol NHS Foundation Trust, said the findings could influence how kidney failure is treated and discussed among older patients worldwide.

"Our findings could have global implications for how kidney failure is discussed and managed in older patients," he said.

He stressed that patients should be given clear information about both treatment options and supported in making decisions that reflect their personal needs and priorities.

Patients should be told the "pros and cons of both" treatments and "supported to make the choice that fits their priorities for care", he added.

The nine-year research involved almost 500 patients, most of whom were over the age of 80. Many participants also had other serious health conditions, including heart disease and cancer.

Participants were randomly assigned to one of two treatment approaches: preparation for dialysis or a structured programme of responsive management at home.

Over an average follow-up period of 4.5 years, researchers found that neither approach was superior when life expectancy and quality of life were considered together.

Caskey explained that "neither treatment option was superior to the other, but both provided similar overall length and quality of life".

He, however, emphasised that dialysis remains an important and potentially life-saving treatment, particularly for younger people with kidney failure.

"It is life-saving for younger people but it is a huge undertaking for patients," he said.

According to Caskey, dialysis typically requires hospital visits three times a week, with each session lasting at least four hours, a demanding routine that "can be very exhausting" for older patients.

The research also found that participants in both treatment groups were more likely to die from other causes than to eventually require dialysis, highlighting the complex health challenges faced by older people with kidney failure.

For 77-year-old Lynn Watts, from Kingswood in South Gloucestershire, the study has provided an opportunity to manage her condition without immediately undergoing the demanding treatment.

Watts said she initially thought the "end was near" when she was diagnosed with kidney failure almost five years ago.

Although she was prepared to undergo dialysis if her symptoms worsened, she was concerned about the amount of time the treatment would take away from her daily life.

She said she "didn't want three days taken out" of her life every week.

Watts joined the study in January 2024 and was randomly assigned to the alternative treatment approach. Her kidney function has remained fairly stable since then.

Reflecting on life with the condition, she said: "It's slowed my life down. I'm not running about and doing gardening... like I used to."

She added: "I'm still alive and that's how I look at it."

Meanwhile, Kidney Care UK estimates that approximately 7.2 million people in the UK are living with some level of chronic kidney disease, although most are in the earlier stages of the condition.

Fiona Loud, from the charity, said the research provides an opportunity for patients and healthcare professionals to consider how treatment decisions align with individual priorities, particularly towards the end of life.

She said the study could help patients make "balanced and informed choices which are flexible".

The findings highlight the importance of individualised care, allowing older people with kidney failure to weigh the potential benefits and demands of dialysis against alternative approaches to managing their condition.