In a letter dated October 3, 2023 to the Chevron Nigeria
Closed Pension Funds Administration (CNCPFA), PenCoN through its counsel, Evans
Ufeli noted that the body is registered under the Corporate Affairs Commission
(CAC) and as guaranteed under the 1999 Constitution (as altered) and under the
inherent provision of the right to the freedom of association.
Ufeli argued that Chevron Retirees Association of Nigeria
(CRAN) is not registered and constituted as an incorporated Trustee, adding
that it only did that after PenCoN had been registered.
Ufeli further argued that CRAN was first formed as an
entity, but same, at the time, lacked the legal capacity to represent
pensioners (retirees), owing to the unambiguous fact that it was indeed,
registered/incorporated as a limited liability company, consequently stripping
itself of the legal capacity to represent retirees, while PenCoN was fully
incorporated on October 28, 2022, vesting same with full powers and the
requisite capacity to represent the interests of retirees who willfully opted
for membership of same.
The letter reads: “Your body has failed, neglected and/or
willfully refused to recognise our client (having been fully incorporated first
with the requisite legal capacity to represent retirees, and properly
constituted under the extant laws of the federation) more so, being approved as
a legitimate body corporate by the laws of Nigeria as a separate legal, entity
distinct from its members, whilst entrenched with the capacity to sue and be
sued. In spite of numerous entreaties the same had made to your office in the
past for due and deserved recognition, your office/body has yet to deem it fit
to reckon with our client in the interest of all concerned.”
Citing some sections of the 1999 Constitution of Nigeria (as
altered) Ufeli stated: “Every person shall be entitled to assemble freely and
associate with other persons, and in particular, he may form or belong to any
political party, trade union or any other association for the protection of his
interests.
“In section 16(1)(d), the 1999 Constitution provides that
the State shall, within the context of the ideals and objectives for which
provisions are made in this Constitution that suitable and adequate shelter,
suitable and adequate food, reasonable national minimum living wage, old age
care and pensions, and unemployment, sick benefits and welfare of the disabled
are provided for all citizens.”
He continues: “In the case under reference, your body by its
poignant action, has inadvertently fostered an atmosphere of differences,
stimulated by its preference to deal with CRAN at the expense of our client,
thereby flaring the embers of hostility, leaving a bitter taste in the mouth of
concerned and affected Nigerian citizens, who all gave a better part of their
youth and adult lives serving your organisation meritoriously.
“The atmosphere, environment and psychological
disequilibrium created so far by your organisation in the case under reference
is counter-productive and stemming from the aforestated, it is deducible that
these extant constitutional and statutory provisions have all been breached by
your organisation therein, owing to your body’s willful neglect of the legal
and lawful existence of our client as a lawful entity saddled with aims and
objectives therein (for which have been lawfully formulated), as well as switching
to engage CRAN, allegedly on behalf of members (retirees), devoid of the due
and authorised consent of same, hence our demand letter.”
The lawyer, therefore, demanded that the organisation acts
accordingly by paying cognisance to his client, being a duly registered body
corporate having its registered office at No. 1, Adenowo Mabadeje Street,
Ebute-Igbogbo Road, Ikorodu, Lagos State.
He also called for a forum with them to appraise their
grievances of non-recognition of its lawfully constituted management, in the
interest and benefit of its members, who happen to be retired staff of the
company.
He, therefore, threatened to take legal action if CNCPFA
failed to meet or address the letter.
“PenCoN is concerned with the outsourcing of CNCPFA without
prior engagement with her members or their representatives. There is no section
of the PRA- 2014 that empowers the employer to unilaterally move retirees’
funds from in-house closed pension funds to a third-party pension funds
administrator. This will also be tested in the court of law,” Ufeli declared.